Troubleshooting Common Problems with Coffee Makers

Mornings are rough enough without your coffee maker deciding to rebel. Whether it’s brewing slowly, making coffee that tastes off, or refusing to brew at all, a misbehaving coffee machine can throw off your entire routine.

The good news? Most common coffee maker issues have simple fixes. This guide breaks down frequent problems and how to solve them, so you can get back to enjoying a perfect cup. While solutions can vary by brand and model, these troubleshooting tips should point you in the right direction—just be sure to check your manual for anything specific to your machine!

Common Coffee Maker Problems

Why is my coffee maker so slow?

⚠️ Problem: Mineral buildup (scaling)

Over time, minerals from your water can accumulate inside the coffee maker, clogging the system and slowing down brewing.

✅ Fix: Descale your coffee maker

Descale your machine regularly. Fill the reservoir with a mixture of equal parts white vinegar and water, run a brewing cycle halfway, pause for 30 minutes, then complete the cycle. Finish by running 2-3 cycles with fresh water to rinse.

⚠️ Problem: Clogged components

Coffee grounds and oils can build up, especially in the filter basket and water lines, restricting water flow (and slowing your machine down).

✅ Fix: Clean the machine

Clean removable parts after each use. For deeper cleaning, refer to your machine’s manual for guidance on accessing and cleaning internal components.

⚠️ Problem: Dirty heating element

A heating element coated with residue can’t heat water efficiently, leading to slower brewing.

✅ Fix: Clean the heating element

Regular descaling helps, but occasionally inspect the heating element for buildup and clean it. Using a vinegar and water mixture (1:1) and then wiping it off should work, but if you have more buildup, you can also use the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning solution.

⚠️ Problem: Low water temperature

If the water isn’t reaching the optimal brewing temperature, extraction slows down.

✅ Fix: Plug in properly

Ensure your machine is plugged into a proper outlet and hasn’t been on for an extended period without use, as some models reduce temperature over time. You should also check your temperature settings. Ideally, it should be between 195-205°F (90-96°C), so consult your user manual to see which setting uses these temperatures.

⚠️ Problem: Incorrect grind size

Using a grind that’s too fine can cause over-extraction and slow brewing.

✅ Fix: Choose medium grind

Opt for a medium grind for drip coffee makers to balance flavor and brewing time.

Why does my coffee taste off?

⚠️ Problem: Mineral buildup

Over time, coffee oils and mineral deposits can accumulate in your machine, leading to off-flavors.

✅ Fix: Clean your coffee maker regularly

Regular cleaning is essential to maintain optimal taste. Rinse removable parts like the carafe and filter basket daily with warm, soapy water. Once a month, descale your machine using a solution specifically designed for coffee makers to remove mineral buildup.

⚠️ Problem: Stale or weak coffee

Stale or low-quality beans can result in a flat or unpleasant taste.

✅ Fix: Use fresh, high-quality coffee beans

Use beans roasted within the last two weeks and grind them just before brewing. Keep beans in an airtight container away from light, heat, and moisture.

⚠️ Problem: Poor water quality or temperature

Water quality and temperature significantly impact coffee flavor.

✅ Fix: Use filtered water at optimal brewing temperatures

Since poor quality tap water can make your coffee taste off, try using filtered water instead. Avoid distilled water since it could make your coffee taste flat.

You should also make sure that you’re brewing at the right temperature — between 195°F and 205°F (90°C to 96°C). Water that’s too hot or too cold can lead to bitter or sour notes.

⚠️ Problem: Incorrect grind size

Grind size affects how your coffee extracts. If it’s too fine, your coffee can taste bitter. Too coarse? It might be weak.

✅ Fix: Check Grind Size and Consistency

Match the grind to your brewing method (e.g., coarse for French press, medium for drip, fine for espresso). Use a burr grinder to get uniform particle sizes, preventing over- or under-extraction.

⚠️ Problem: A plastic or chemical taste

New coffee makers or certain parts can give off a plastic or chemical taste.

✅ Fix: Run a few cycles with water

Run several cycles with water only to flush out residues. If the taste is still off, consider wiping down internal plastic parts with alcohol or running a diluted vinegar solution through the machine, followed by multiple water-only cycles.

Why is my coffee cold?

⚠️ Problem: Faulty heating element or thermostat

If your coffee maker isn’t heating water properly, a malfunctioning heating element or thermostat could be the culprit.

✅ Fix: Inspect and replace damaged components

• Unplug the machine: Make sure that the coffee maker is disconnected from the power source.
• Access internal parts: Refer to your user manual to locate and access the heating element and thermostat.
• Examine for damage: Look for signs of wear or damage. There would be cracks or deformation visible to the eye.
• Replace if necessary: If you’re comfortable with DIY repairs, replace faulty parts. Otherwise, consult a professional technician.

⚠️ Problem: Mineral buildup

Over time, mineral deposits from hard water can accumulate, slowing down the heating process.

✅ Fix: Descale your coffee maker

Run a simple descaling cycle and this should clear up all the mineral buildup. If you haven’t done this in a while and there’s more buildup than normal, then a few descaling cycles might help.

⚠️ Problem: Inadequate warm-up time

Some coffee makers require a few minutes to reach optimal brewing temperature.

✅ Fix: Allow proper preheating

To fix this, activate your coffee maker and then let it warm up for 1-2 minutes before starting the brew cycle.

⚠️ Problem: Incorrect brew settings

Modern coffee makers often have adjustable temperature settings.

✅ Fix: Verify and adjust settings

Review your coffee maker’s instructions to locate temperature controls. Set the brewing temperature to your desired level.

⚠️ Problem: Malfunctioning keep-warm plate

If the warming plate isn’t functioning, brewed coffee can cool quickly.

✅ Fix: Test and repair the warming plate

• Unplug the machine and wait for the warming plate to cool: After brewing, unplug your machine and wait for the warming plate to cool completely. To make sure it’s fully cool, you can touch it while using kitchen mittens (safety first!).
• Clean the Plate: Clean the plate to remove residue that might affect its performance.
• Seek Professional Help: If the plate remains cold, it may need repair or replacement by a technician.

How to fix a coffee maker that won’t brew

⚠️ Problem: Lack of power supply

If your coffee maker doesn’t turn on, it may not be receiving power.

✅ Fix: Check the power connection

• Verify the outlet: Plug another device into the same outlet to ensure it’s functioning.
• Inspect the power cord: Look for any visible damage to the cord.
• Confirm the power switch: Make sure that the coffee maker’s power switch is turned on.

⚠️ Problem: Clogged water lines (and other parts)

Mineral deposits or coffee grounds can block water flow, preventing brewing.

✅ Fix: Clean the coffee maker

Run a descaling cycle and then a few water-only cycles (to clear the chemical or vinegar taste).

⚠️ Problem: Misaligned parts

If parts like the filter basket or water reservoir aren’t properly positioned, the machine may not operate.

✅ Fix: Make sure everything is assembled properly

For safety, disconnect the machine from the power source. Check if all removable parts are correctly aligned and securely in place. If not, assemble the machine properly. Then you can plug the machine back in and attempt to brew.

⚠️ Problem: Faulty heating element

If the water isn’t heating, the heating element may be defective.

✅ Fix: Assess and replace if necessary

Unplug your machine and check the heating element. Use the user manual so you can get a good idea what might be wrong. Usually, you’ll need to check for signs of wear or corrosion. If anything is damaged, it’s best to contact a qualified technician.

Why is my coffee maker leaking?

⚠️ Problem: Cracked water reservoir

Over time, the plastic water reservoir can develop cracks, leading to leaks.

✅ Fix: Inspect and replace the reservoir

Detach the reservoir from the machine and empty any remaining water. Hold it up to the light to spot any hairline fractures. Putting water back in might also help to find where it’s leaking. If you find any cracks, you should contact the manufacturer for a replacement part.

⚠️ Problem: Worn-out gaskets and seals

Rubber gaskets and seals can deteriorate, causing water to escape.

✅ Fix: Inspect and replace gaskets

• Unplug the machine: Make sure it’s disconnected from the power source and completely cool.
• Access the seals: Your user manual should be able to tell you where gaskets and seals are.
• Check for wear: Gaskets and seals that need replacing will usually look torn or worn out. They can also look hardened and brittle.
• Replace as needed: Get the correct parts from the manufacturer and install them. If you’re not comfortable with DIY fixes, you can also contact a technician.

⚠️ Problem: Clogged overflow valve

Mineral buildup can block the overflow valve, leading to leaks.

✅ Fix: Clean the overflow valve

Fixing this is simple and easy — all you need to do is run a descaling cycle.

⚠️ Problem: Damaged carafe

A cracked or chipped carafe can cause leaks during brewing.

✅ Fix: Inspect and replace the carafe

Look for visible cracks or chips. If you can’t see anything immediately, fill it with water and watch out for any leaks. If you spot some, get a new carafe (but make sure to check the make and model before you do).

⚠️ Problem: Loose or misaligned parts

Improper assembly can lead to water escaping from unintended areas.

✅ Fix: Reassemble correctly

Unplug your coffee maker and make sure it’s cooled off completely. Take out all removable parts (like the filter basket and water reservoir). After that, put them back into their place but make sure they are aligned properly. Check for leaks again by running a brew cycle with water only.

Why is my coffee maker making loud noises?

⚠️ Problem: Mineral buildup (scaling)

If your machine sounds like it’s struggling or hissing, mineral deposits from hard water might be clogging things up.

✅ Fix: Run a descaling cycle

Simply descale your coffee maker and then run 2 or 3 cycles with water only to clear out any vinegar/chemical smells.

⚠️ Problem: Clogged water lines

If it’s making gurgling or sputtering noises, coffee grounds or mineral buildup might be blocking the tubes.

✅ Fix: Clear out clogs

Unplug the machine and check for any visible debris. Use a thin brush or pipe cleaner to clear out any clogs.

⚠️ Problem: Air trapped in the system

If your coffee maker sounds like it’s gasping for air, air might be trapped in the system.

✅ Fix: Run a brew cycle without coffee

Try filling the water reservoir to the max and running a brew cycle without coffee. That should push out any trapped air bubbles.

Why is my coffee maker producing weak coffee?

⚠️ Problem: Coffee-to-water ratio is off

If you’re using too much water or too little coffee grounds, your coffee will come out weak.

✅ Fix: Use the right amount of coffee

Try using about 1 to 2 tablespoons of coffee per 6 ounces of water. If you’re using a scoop, make sure it’s leveled.

⚠️ Problem: Grind size is too coarse

If the coffee grounds are too large, water flows through too quickly, leading to under-extraction.

✅ Fix: Grind (or buy) finer

If you’re grinding your own beans, go finer—but not too fine, or you’ll over-extract and get bitterness.

⚠️ Problem: Water temperature is too low

The ideal brewing temp is 195-205°F (90-96°C). If your machine doesn’t heat properly, the coffee won’t extract well.

✅ Fix: Check if the temperature is high enough

Run a brew cycle with just water and check if it’s hot enough. If not, your heating element might be failing.

⚠️ Problem: Dirty Machine

Mineral buildup and old coffee oils can mess with extraction and make it taste off as well.

✅ Fix: Descale your coffee maker

Descale with equal parts vinegar and water, then rinse with fresh water a few times.

⚠️ Problem: Brewing Time Is Too Short

Some machines rush the process, which makes the coffee come out too weak.

✅ Fix: Use a longer brewing setting

If yours has a “bold” or “strong” setting, turn it on—it slows extraction for a richer brew.

💡 Pro Tip: If none of these fix your problem and your coffee is still weak, you should try a darker roast or a fresh bag of beans—stale coffee won’t give you that strong flavor, no matter what you do!

Why does my coffee maker smell bad?

⚠️ Problem: Old coffee oils and residue

Over time, coffee oils and fine grounds build up inside the machine, leading to a bad smell.

✅ Fix: Deep clean the removable parts

Take out the filter basket, carafe, and any other removable parts. Wash them with warm, soapy water and rinse thoroughly. If there’s stubborn residue, soak in a mix of vinegar and water (1:1) for 15 minutes.

⚠️ Problem: Mold and bacteria in the water reservoir

A warm, damp coffee maker is the perfect breeding ground for mold and bacteria.

✅ Fix: Descale and sanitize

If there’s visible mold in the water reservoir, make sure that you clean it all off by using soapy, warm water and a gentle sponge. After that, run a descaling cycle. You might need to run it a few times to ensure there are no bacteria and mold leftover.

However, if there is a lot of mold in your coffee maker, it’s best to replace that part or the whole machine — you don’t want to risk your health!

⚠️ Problem: Stagnant water sitting in the machine

Leaving water in the reservoir for too long can make it smell stale.

✅ Fix: Keep it fresh

Always empty leftover water after each use. Wipe the reservoir dry to prevent bacteria growth. Use fresh, cold water every time you brew.

⚠️ Problem: Burnt coffee smell

Leaving coffee sitting on the warming plate too long can create a lingering burnt odor.

✅ Fix: Clean the warming plate and carafe

Wash the carafe after every use (yes, every use!). Wipe down the warming plate with a damp cloth to remove any burnt coffee residue.

💡 Pro Tip: To keep your coffee maker smelling fresh, run a vinegar rinse once a month and always clean up spills right away. Your nose (and your coffee) will thank you!

Why is my coffee maker not dispensing water?

⚠️ Problem: Mineral Buildup Clogging the Tubes

If you have hard water, mineral deposits can block the water flow over time.

✅ Fix: Run a Descaling Cycle

Running a standard descaling cycle will clear the clogged water lines. If your machine hasn’t been descaled in a while, you might need to run a few. Make sure to repeat this process monthly to avoid this issue in the future.

⚠️ Problem: Air bubbles in the system

If the machine was moved or ran dry, air bubbles can block water flow.

✅ Fix: Prime the pump

• Turn off and unplug the machine.
• Fill the water reservoir.
• Tilt the coffee maker gently side to side to dislodge any trapped air.
• Plug it back in and try brewing again.

⚠️ Problem: Clogged filter or water line

Old coffee grounds or debris can clog the filter, stopping water from flowing.

✅ Fix: Clean or replace the filter

Remove the filter (if your machine has one) and rinse it under running water. If it’s reusable, clean it with a soft brush and soapy water. For machines with a water line, check for blockages and clean them out with a thin brush or pipe cleaner.

Inspect for any damage — you might need to replace parts if there’s wear and tear.

⚠️ Problem: Heating Element Malfunction

If your coffee maker isn’t heating up, water won’t move through the system.

✅ Fix: Test with hot water

Unplug the machine and let it cool. Pour hot (not boiling) water into the reservoir and try running a brew cycle. If it works, your heating element may be failing, and it’s time to contact the manufacturer or consider a replacement.

Why is my coffee maker overflowing the grounds basket?

⚠️ Problem: Using the wrong grind size

If your coffee is ground too finely (like espresso grind), water can’t flow through properly, leading to an overflow.

✅ Fix: Use a coarser grind

Switch to a medium or medium-coarse grind — it should feel like sand, not powder. If you’re using pre-ground coffee, try a different brand labeled for drip machines.

⚠️ Problem: Too much coffee in the basket

Overloading the filter with coffee leads to slow drainage and messy spills.

✅ Fix: Measure your coffee

Use 1 to 2 tablespoons per 6 ounces of water (or follow your machine’s guidelines). If you’re filling the basket to the brim—it’s too much! Leave some space for water flow.

⚠️ Problem: Clogged or wet paper filter

A wet, collapsed, or clogged filter blocks water from flowing through evenly.

✅ Fix: Check and replace the filter

If you’re using a paper filter, make sure it’s properly placed and dry before adding coffee. If you’re using a permanent filter, wash it thoroughly to remove old coffee oils and buildup.

⚠️ Problem: Slow drainage

Over time, coffee grounds and mineral deposits can clog the bottom of the filter basket, causing slow drainage.

✅ Fix: Unclog the basket

• Remove the basket and wash it with warm, soapy water.
• Check the exit hole at the bottom—if clogged, use a toothpick or small brush to clear it.
• Run a vinegar cycle to break down hidden buildup (equal parts white vinegar and water, followed by 2 cycles of clean water).

💡 Pro Tip: To avoid overflows, use the right grind, the right amount of coffee, and keep your filter basket clean.

Coffee Maker Maintenance & Care

Want to keep your coffee maker brewing without issues? Regular maintenance isn’t just about preventing breakdowns — it also improves flavor and extends the life of your machine. Here’s how to keep it in top shape:

Daily Cleaning

• Empty & rinse the carafe and filter basket after every use.
• Wipe down the machine with a damp cloth to remove spills and coffee oils.
• Always use fresh, cold water to prevent mineral buildup.
• Keep your coffee maker dry and unplugged when not in use to prevent electrical damage.
• Never leave used coffee grounds in the machine for too long, as they can start to mold.

Weekly Cleaning

• Wash the removable parts (filter basket, carafe, reservoir) with warm, soapy water.
• Check the filter for clogs and rinse it thoroughly.
• Scrub the warming plate to remove burnt coffee stains.

Monthly Maintenance: Descale & Sanitize

Over time, mineral deposits from water can clog the system, affecting performance.

• Run a descaling cycle.
• Check for wear and tear—replace gaskets, filters, and seals as needed.

💡 Pro Tip: If you have hard water, descale your coffee maker every 2–3 weeks for the best results. A well-maintained machine means better-tasting coffee and fewer breakdowns!

FAQ