There are numerous reasons to select a small loudspeaker that’s designed to sit on a bookshelf or on a dedicated speaker stand, and they’re all perfectly valid. Some of them are aesthetic, some are concerned with practicalities, and some are to do with performance — but none of them should prevent you from enjoying thoroughly satisfying sound quality, no matter how compact and unobtrusive a loudspeaker you select.
This guide will show you what features to look for when buying a passive bookshelf speaker and what makes it different from an active speaker as well. Let’s get into it.
Bass Limitations in Smaller Speakers
There are accommodations to be made, of course, when you’re getting a bookshelf speaker. The smaller mid/bass drivers that smaller loudspeakers are fitted with cannot generate the sort of air movement that delivers the deepest bass sounds, so many manufacturers fit their loudspeakers with bass reflex ports in order to offer some additional low-frequency reinforcement.
For bookshelf speakers, a mid/bass driver of around 5–6.5 inches is common. Anything smaller than 5 inches will struggle with bass depth, while anything larger pushes into standmount or floorstanding territory.
How Bass Reflex Ports Work
A bass reflex port makes use of the air movement generated by the back of the speaker cone that would otherwise remain inside the cabinet (where it could conceivably create issues around unwanted resonance or vibration). It concentrates this air movement into a port (essentially a pipe) in order to create low-frequency sound waves.
Front vs. Rear Ports
If the port is facing forwards and shares the front baffle of the speaker with the drivers, it tends to be a little less effective but also a little less problematic than the rear-facing alternative. Those bookshelf/standmount speakers with rear-facing bass reflex ports demand you give more consideration to where exactly in your room they are to be positioned – because if you move the speaker closer to the fixed boundary of the wall behind it, the effect of the port will become more pronounced as the sound waves reflect from the wall.
This is not automatically a good thing – the output of the reflex port might ‘bloom’ and start to dominate the midrange frequencies above if the back of the speaker is too close to the wall. Move it further away and the effect will be lessened, ultimately to the point that it becomes difficult to discern.
Try to leave at least 6–12 inches of space between the rear of a rear-ported speaker and the wall. In smaller rooms, forward-firing ports are usually easier to integrate.
Think About Your Space
Even though a properly designed bass reflex port can help a smaller speaker generate low-frequency presence that would otherwise be the preserve of a larger speaker, it’s important to bear in mind that smaller cabinets, with their smaller internal volume, tend to produce an overall scale of sound that is less impressive than that delivered by larger cabinets.
It’s obvious when you think about it: the smaller cabinet means smaller drivers, which in turn means less air displacement, which ultimately means less expansive sound.
This shouldn’t be too much of an issue in an average-sized living room, but if you have a bigger space you intend to fill with sound, or if you crave the sort of full-scale presentation that suits orchestral music in particular, the smaller cabinet option may not be for you.
For rooms under 200 sq. ft., compact bookshelf speakers (with drivers around 5 inches) are usually sufficient. Larger rooms (300+ sq. ft.) will benefit from either bigger standmounts (6.5–7 inch drivers) or adding a subwoofer.
Consider Where to Position Your Speakers
The temptation with very small speakers is to put them in a position that finds them surrounded on two or even three sides by very nearby boundaries. After all, the description “bookshelf” does seem to strongly imply that a speaker can exist happily on a shelf with books on either side and a wall right behind it.
But any loudspeaker, no matter its physical dimensions, does its best work when given a little free space in which to operate. If you can avoid boxing your loudspeaker in a corner or surrounding it with books (for instance) on a shelf, the better it is likely to sound.
Position speakers so their tweeters are at ear height when seated, angled slightly toward the listening position. Aim for at least a foot of clearance from side walls for balanced imaging.
Shelf or Stands?
If you’re going to be positioning your loudspeaker on a shelf, it’s worth trying to decouple it from the shelf as much as possible. If the entire base of the speaker is in contact with the shelf, then low-frequency sound waves (in particular) are inclined to travel downwards as much as they are forwards. All that’s required is a little blob of Blu-tac (or similar) in each corner of the bottom of the speaker to significantly reduce the amount of contact it has with the shelf – and the differences in sound will be apparent.
If you’re using a dedicated speaker stand, though, this will all have been taken care of for you. The stand will be decoupled from the floor using spikes or small pliant feet. And the top-plate (which the speaker sits on) will have a slightly more hi-tech version of the “Blu-tac” arrangement to decouple the speaker. The upshot is a speaker that’s barely contacting the stand, and a stand that’s barely contacting the floor. Which is ideal.
To Grille or Not to Grille
Almost every passive bookshelf/standmount loudspeaker will be supplied with grilles. They are usually intended to offer a small amount of protection to the drive units, as well as to provide a cleaner and less assertive look – and they are usually made from acoustic cloth to allow the drivers to operate as freely as possible.
There’s no denying that the drivers will perform to their fullest if the grilles are not in place, though – so it’s worth making sure you can live with the visual statement a pair of speakers makes when its grilles are removed. And it may also be worth checking how the grilles are attached in the first place – if they use little magnetic patches, it means the front face of the loudspeaker won’t have any unsightly lug-holes spoiling its appearance.
Is Your Amplifier Up to the Task?
As we’re discussing passive loudspeakers here, they need to be driven by an external amplifier that’s connected via a length of speaker cable – or two lengths, if the loudspeaker can be bi-wired.
Examine the specifications of your prospective loudspeaker – any worthwhile manufacturer will publish them on its website. Then be sure to pay special attention to the sensitivity, impedance, total harmonic distortion, and power-handling figures.
- Sensitivity: 86–88 dB is typical; above 90 dB is considered efficient and easier to drive.
- Impedance: 8 ohms is standard; 4 ohms may need a stronger amplifier.
- Power handling: Match your amp’s RMS power output to the speaker’s recommended range (e.g., a 50–100W per channel amp for a 50–150W speaker).
- Total Harmonic Distortion (THD): The lower the better; under 1% is standard, but many quality speakers rate far below this.
What to Listen For
You can’t realistically expect bone-shaking bass response or hangar-filling scale of sound from a relatively small loudspeaker, but you’re certainly entitled to expect good levels of detail retrieval – it’s the details that make up a complete sonic picture, after all.
Expect decent dynamic headroom, too – the ability to put a big distance between the quietest and loudest moments in a recording can really make it come to life. Confident rhythmic expression is important as well – bass sounds that start and stop promptly, rather than slurring, help with sonic momentum and can make a loudspeaker sound lively.
Having said that, there’s no getting around the fact that “good sound” is a subjective thing. If you decide you prefer sound “A” to sound “B,” then no one is in a position to disagree with you.
When auditioning, listen for clear vocals, precise instrument separation, and bass that is tight rather than boomy. Try using tracks with wide dynamic swings (like classical or jazz) and rhythm-driven music (like funk or rock) to test a speaker’s versatility.