Air Fryer vs. Convection Oven: Which Is Right For You?

If you’ve been resisting getting an air fryer, because they look like convection ovens – at least on paper – you’re not half wrong. They’re not quite the same, however. Yes, air fryers are small convection ovens. But the size differential separates these two types of kitchen appliances in more than just how much food they can cook at once.

I’ll dive into what both an air fryer and a convection oven are as well as how they’re different.

Air Fryer vs. Convection Oven: Overview

What’s an Air Fryer?

An air fryer is a small convection oven — a cooking device that uses the same type of heat to cook food. It has an internal cavity for cooking like a convection oven, but much smaller, and uses a heating element – usually just one situated at the top or back of the unit – with a fan behind to circulate the hot air forming around that heating element to evenly cook whatever you put in it.

Air fryers are small enough that they can usually fit on top of a counter and be packed away when not used. Even the biggest ones, such as the oven-style models, are just a little larger than a toaster oven or microwave.

What’s a Convection Oven?

A convection oven is essentially a regular oven with one addition: fans. It uses similar heating elements, usually a couple at the bottom and/or top with a fan or two to evenly distribute the hot air, which, like an air fryer, results in faster and more even cooking.

Convection ovens are typically the same size as regular ovens, taking up a large space in a kitchen. They’re not portable like an air fryer and can’t be packed away when not in use. They often also can disengage the internal fans to be used like a regular oven, which uses radiant heat to cook.

What’s the Difference Between an Air Fryer and a Convection Oven?

Size and Cooking Capacity

There’s mainly one physical difference between an air fryer and a convection oven, and that’s its size.

• Air fryers are compact, designed to sit on a countertop, and usually have a capacity ranging from 2 to 8 quarts.
• Convection ovens are much larger — either full-sized wall units or countertop models with capacities starting around 10 quarts and going up significantly from there.

This difference impacts not just how much food you can cook at once, but also how you cook it. A standard air fryer can comfortably handle meals for one to two people. Trying to cook a large batch often means working in multiple rounds, which can affect timing and texture.

Even the larger “family-sized” air fryers are limited by their basket shape — often tall and narrow — so while you might have enough total volume, usable surface area is restricted. Foods that need to lie flat, like breaded cutlets or delicate fish, can’t always fit without crowding.

Convection ovens offer more flexibility. Their interior design supports multiple racks and larger pans, which allows you to bake a sheet tray of cookies, roast a whole chicken with vegetables, or prepare multiple dishes simultaneously.

You can also use different types of bakeware, including glass, ceramic, and metal, with fewer restrictions than in an air fryer, which often requires specific airflow-compatible accessories.

One less obvious factor is how food spacing affects cooking performance. Air fryers depend heavily on unobstructed airflow to crisp properly. If the basket is overcrowded — even slightly — results can vary. In contrast, convection ovens generally recover from crowding better, especially if they have a strong fan system, because the airflow circulates around larger, open spaces rather than through a compact basket.

So while an air fryer is ideal for quick meals and snacks, smaller families or people with limited space, a convection oven is better suited for batch cooking, baking, or preparing full meals at once.

Fan Use

The second major difference between air fryers and convection ovens is how the fan system works and how much control you have over it.

• Convection ovens are more versatile in this regard — they allow you to turn the fan on or off, effectively switching between convection cooking and traditional radiant-heat baking. This flexibility is crucial for certain recipes. Delicate baked goods like soufflés, custards, and some cakes are sensitive to airflow; a strong fan can cause them to collapse, brown unevenly, or develop a tough exterior before the interior is fully cooked.
• Air fryers, on the other hand, always cook with the fan running. Even oven-style air fryers, which may resemble small convection ovens, don’t usually offer an option to disable the fan. This limits their use for recipes that require still, gentle heat. Because of their compact size and powerful fans positioned close to the food, air fryers produce a more intense and focused airflow than traditional convection ovens. This can speed up cooking but also increases the risk of drying out or disturbing delicate foods.

Internally, both appliances use a combination of a heating element and a fan to circulate hot air. However, convection ovens generally have multiple heating elements (sometimes at the top and bottom) and a larger fan, or even multiple fans in higher-end models. This setup allows for more even heat distribution across a wider space and more consistent cooking over time.

Air fryers typically use a single heating element and fan mounted at the top, concentrating heat in a smaller area, which is why they cook food faster and with crispier results — ideal for things like fries, wings, and frozen snacks.

Some newer convection ovens come with variable-speed fans or specialized modes (e.g., “true convection” or “European convection”) that regulate airflow to better suit different dishes. These features aren’t commonly found in air fryers.

The choice mainly comes down to cooking style and control: if you need flexibility for both baked goods and roasted meals, a convection oven offers more options. If speed and crisp texture are your priorities, the air fryer’s constant fan use works to your advantage.

Preheating Time

Preheating time is one of the areas where air fryers clearly outperform convection ovens.

• Most air fryers require little to no preheating at all — typically 2 to 5 minutes, depending on the model and temperature setting. That’s because their cooking chamber is compact, and the heating element is positioned close to the food. The fan kicks in immediately, pushing hot air around rapidly, which means cooking can begin almost as soon as you turn the unit on.
• Convection ovens, especially full-sized ones, need significantly more time to preheat — often 10 to 15 minutes or more — because they have a much larger interior volume to bring up to temperature. Even countertop convection ovens, though faster than wall-mounted models, still require more time than air fryers due to their larger cavity and thermal mass.

This difference also affects energy usage. While convection ovens are more energy efficient than traditional ovens due to better heat circulation and faster cooking once preheated, they still consume more electricity per session than an air fryer.

Air fryers concentrate heat in a small area, use high-speed fans, and finish cooking faster, which makes them highly efficient for small-portion tasks. For example, reheating leftovers or cooking a single chicken breast takes a fraction of the time and energy in an air fryer compared to a convection oven.

Another subtle factor is temperature recovery. Because of their larger size, convection ovens lose more heat when the door is opened, and it takes longer to return to target temperature. Air fryers, with their closed-lid design and smaller space, recover heat quickly, which helps maintain cooking consistency — especially important when you’re checking on food mid-cook.

In practice, if you’re preparing quick meals, snacks, or small portions, the air fryer’s minimal preheat time gives it a strong advantage. But for baking, roasting multiple trays, or cooking large quantities, the longer preheat and cook time of a convection oven is offset by its ability to handle more food in one go. The trade-off is between speed and scale.

Cleaning

Cleaning is often overlooked when comparing cooking appliances, but it can have a real impact on how often you use them.

Full-sized ovens, including convection ovens, are the most labor-intensive to clean. The larger interior space means more surface area to deal with, especially the walls, floor, and heating elements. Grease splatter, baked-on drips, and carbon buildup accumulate over time, and many ovens require manual scrubbing or harsh oven cleaners unless they have a self-cleaning function, which uses high heat to burn off residue but also consumes significant energy and time.

Convection ovens, whether built-in or countertop models, share the same basic cleaning challenges. While smaller than a full oven, they still involve reaching inside to scrub surfaces that aren’t easily removable. Most have removable racks and crumb trays, which help a bit, but if food spills or grease splashes on the internal walls or ceiling, cleaning becomes awkward and time-consuming. The heating elements are usually exposed, and you need to clean around them carefully to avoid damage or fire risk.

Air fryers offer a simpler cleaning process, especially the basket-style models. These typically have a nonstick-coated basket and drawer, both of which are removable and often dishwasher safe. Even if washing by hand, these parts fit easily in the sink and can be scrubbed with minimal effort. Because the cooking chamber is small and enclosed, splatter is contained, which keeps the appliance itself cleaner over time.

Oven-style air fryers, however, fall somewhere in between. While the trays and crumb catcher are removable, the internal walls and ceiling are not. If food splatters, you’ll need to clean inside the unit much like a traditional oven — reaching into corners, navigating around heating elements, and wiping down awkward surfaces. The nonstick coatings on some models help, but they still require regular maintenance to avoid buildup and odors. Also, because these appliances often cook at high heat, any residue left inside can smoke during the next use.

One often-overlooked detail is fan maintenance. In convection ovens and air fryers alike, grease and food particles can get pulled into the fan over time, especially if you’re cooking fatty foods. While some high-end convection ovens have filters or self-cleaning options, most air fryers don’t offer easy access to clean the fan, which can affect performance and create unpleasant smells if not periodically wiped down (if the design allows for it).

Overall, basket-style air fryers are the easiest to clean on a regular basis. Oven-style air fryers and convection ovens require more effort, particularly if spills or grease splatters aren’t dealt with immediately.

Health Benefits

Both air fryers and convection ovens are often marketed as healthier alternatives to traditional frying methods, and in most cases, the health benefits are nearly identical. The core similarity lies in how both appliances use circulating hot air to achieve a crispy texture with minimal or no added oil.

For example, deep-frying a serving of French fries can add 200–300 extra calories from oil alone. Cooking the same portion in an air fryer or convection oven using just one teaspoon of oil — or none at all — can cut that number by more than half. The result is food with lower saturated fat and fewer trans fats, especially important for people managing cholesterol or heart disease risk.

Where the two differ slightly is in how the cooking process might affect texture, which can influence how much oil you end up using.

• Air fryers, with their smaller chambers and more concentrated airflow, often produce a crispier result without as much added fat. Because of that, users may be more satisfied with less oil.
• In convection ovens, especially large ones, you might find yourself adding more oil to achieve a similar texture — particularly for breaded or starchy foods like sweet potato fries or chicken tenders.

You also need to look at how each appliance handles grease from the food itself. In a basket-style air fryer, fat drips away from the food and collects in the bottom drawer, which can slightly reduce the final fat content of meats like bacon, sausage, or chicken thighs. Some convection ovens have drip trays, but depending on the pan and setup, the food may sit in its own rendered fat as it cooks.

Another consideration is the type of cookware and liners used. Nonstick baskets and trays in air fryers may degrade over time, especially if scratched or overheated, potentially exposing users to small amounts of PTFE (Teflon) or other coating materials. High-end convection ovens often use stainless steel interiors, which may be more durable over years of high-heat cooking. While these differences are minimal from a nutritional standpoint, they can matter to people concerned with long-term chemical exposure.

In terms of nutrient retention, both appliances perform well. Because they cook quickly and don’t require boiling or heavy oil immersion, vitamins and minerals in vegetables are generally preserved better than in traditional stovetop or deep-frying methods. This makes either a strong choice for people trying to incorporate more roasted or crisped vegetables into their diets without sacrificing nutritional quality.

Ultimately, the health benefits of an air fryer versus a convection oven come down more to portion size, cooking habits, and the types of foods you’re preparing rather than the appliance itself. Both allow for significantly healthier versions of traditionally high-fat meals, as long as you avoid overcompensating with oil or high-calorie coatings.

Price

Price is one of the most noticeable differences between air fryers and convection ovens, and it reflects more than just size but it also speaks to intended use, durability, and versatility.

Air fryers are much more affordable.

• Basic basket-style models can be found for under $100.
• Mid-range options between $120 and $200 offering features like digital controls, preset cooking programs, and slightly larger capacity.
• Higher-end air fryers, especially oven-style models with multiple racks or built-in rotisserie functions, range from $250 to $400. These still sit firmly in the consumer appliance category, and most are designed for countertop use with modest long-term durability.

Convection ovens, on the other hand, are a bigger investment — both financially and physically.

• Countertop convection ovens typically start around $200 but can climb to $600 or more if you want advanced features like air fry modes, smart connectivity, or multiple convection settings.
• Built-in or full-sized convection ovens are in a different league altogether. Entry-level models start around $700, but high-performance units with dual fans, steam functions, programmable temperature zones, or self-cleaning features can cost several thousand dollars.
• Top-tier luxury brands like Gaggenau, Wolf, or Miele offer models that exceed $10,000, but those often combine multiple oven types (convection, steam, warming drawers) in a single unit and are meant for heavy, long-term kitchen use.

It’s worth noting that the price of a convection oven also factors in its role as a central kitchen appliance — it can fully replace your existing oven, which makes the higher cost more justifiable for some users. In contrast, even the most advanced air fryer is still a secondary appliance meant for supplemental cooking.

Repair and maintenance costs are another point of difference.

• Air fryers are relatively inexpensive to replace and rarely worth repairing if they fail out of warranty.
• Convection ovens, especially built-ins, often require professional installation and service, and any major repairs can be costly. This also affects resale or home value—a high-end convection oven can be a selling point in real estate, while an air fryer isn’t a fixed asset.

Should I Buy an Air Fryer or a Convection Oven?

Deciding between an air fryer and a convection oven depends largely on your cooking habits, kitchen setup, and long-term goals.

• In an ideal situation, such as owning your home and planning a full kitchen upgrade, a convection oven is the more versatile and powerful choice. It allows you to cook larger meals, bake with precision, and prepare multiple dishes at once.
• If your current oven is outdated or you’re already remodeling, investing in a convection model can improve both your cooking experience and your home’s value.

However, that scenario isn’t always realistic. Convection ovens are expensive, take up significant space, and may require professional installation.

If you rent, you’re often working with an existing oven that isn’t yours to replace. Even portable countertop convection ovens can be bulky and may not be allowed in smaller kitchens or shared spaces, like studio apartments or dorms. And if you do install a high-end built-in oven, you might not be able to take it with you if you move — something to consider before committing thousands of dollars.

Air fryers, by comparison, are low-risk and easy to adopt. They’re much more affordable, don’t require installation, and work well even in compact kitchens.

• For many people, especially those cooking for one or two, they provide all the functionality needed for daily meals — crisped vegetables, reheated leftovers, roasted proteins—without heating up the whole kitchen or waiting for a long preheat.
• They’re also ideal for renters, students, or anyone with limited space, since you can stash them in a cabinet when not in use.

That said, air fryers do come with some limitations. Batch size is smaller, and cooking larger meals often requires doing it in rounds. Some foods don’t cook as evenly due to space constraints or overcrowding. And because they’re purpose-built for quick, high-heat cooking, they’re not well suited to slow roasting, proofing dough, or baking delicate pastries.

If you cook frequently and for multiple people, or you like to bake, a convection oven is worth considering. But if you’re looking for a convenient, budget-friendly way to make healthier versions of fried or roasted foods, an air fryer is easier to fit into most people’s lifestyles.

FAQs